A COMPLETE SEVEN-PART RUN OF 1913’S ‘THE RETURN OF TARZAN,’ INCLUDING AN EXCEPTIONAL UNRESTORED FIRST INSTALLMENT, BRINGS ONE OF PULP COLLECTING’S GREAT RARITIES TO AUCTION
By Sasha Fraze | November 17, 2026
The All-Story No. 94 from October 1912, featuring Tarzan’s first appearance, is the single most sought-after pulp magazine, the hobby’s Action Comics No. 1 or T206 Honus Wagner, notable for both its groundbreaking influence and impossible rarity. Collectors can spend years looking for the right copy; Bookery’s Guide to Pulps estimates there are “probably fewer than 20 existing copies.” Heritage’s December 4-5 Pulp Magazines Signature® Auction features two copies of that very pulp magazine, a CGC-certified 2.5 and a hardcover bound volume signed by Tarzan’s creator, Edgar Rice Burroughs. That is remarkable, but the auction includes something even rarer and just as important.

After Tarzan’s first appearance in ‘The All-Story’ No. 94, the character quickly became a multimedia sensation, spawning dozens of sequels, film adaptations, television shows, and countless rereleases of his early stories. This copy of the October 1912 issue is available in Heritage’s December 4-5 Pulp Magazines Signature® Auction.
Tarzan’s second appearance (fittingly titled “The Return of Tarzan”) came just a few months later in New Story Magazine. Whereas “Tarzan of the Apes” was included complete in one issue (an unusual choice for the time), his second story was serialized across seven issues from June to December 1913. Those seven comprise some of the rarest and most sought after of all Burroughs pulps. Heritage has seen only four of the seven prior to this auction, and each only once. This auction includes every issue of the seven-part set, with a supremely impressive copy of the story’s opening installment.
New Story Magazine No. 101 from June 1913 is so seldom seen that a trimmed and restored CGC 2.5 copy commanded nearly $11,000 in June of this year. The copy featured here is a CGC 5.0 with off-white to white pages, not just the sole highest-graded copy of that issue (of only two), but the sole highest-graded CGC copy of any issue of New Story Magazine. Almost all key pulps from the 1900s to 1920s have some degree of restoration, but none is present on this copy of Tarzan’s second appearance. In fact, more than half of the seven parts here are unrestored.

From the collection of Robert ‘Bob’ Barrett comes this exceptional unrestored copy of ‘New Story Magazine’ No. 101, featuring the first installment of ‘The Return of Tarzan.’ Heritage’s December 4-5 Pulp Magazines Signature® Auction includes all seven parts of the Edgar Rice Burroughs serial.
This exciting set hails from one of the greatest Edgar Rice Burroughs collections of all time, that of Robert “Bob” Barrett. The Barrett Collection is also responsible for both Burroughs-related Frank Frazetta paintings offered in this month’s Comic Art Signature® Auction, as well as the aforementioned signed volume of “Tarzan of the Apes.” This collection showcases the breadth of Burroughs’ influence, appearing in Signature® auctions across Heritage’s Comics, Comic Art, Illustration Art, Pulps, Rare Books, and Movie Posters departments.

‘New Story Magazine’ No. 102, featuring the second installment of ‘The Return of Tarzan,’ earned a declarative text cover that was impossible for readers to overlook.

For ‘New Story Magazine’ No. 103, Tarzan made his third cover appearance courtesy of N.C. Wyeth.
Burroughs was the George Lucas of his day: an artist whose storytelling skills were matched only by his prescience for marketing and franchising. His characters John Carter and Tarzan quickly jumped across pulp magazines, books, movies, comic strips, comic books, and more, appearing in each medium as they advanced in the early days of the 20th century.
For the unaware, John Carter is a Confederate soldier who finds himself whisked away to Mars, where his earthly human nature gives him inexplicable powers. He first appeared in “Under the Moons of Mars” (later known as A Princess of Mars), which ran in The All-Story just a few months prior to “Tarzan of the Apes.” Also hailing from the Barrett Collection, this auction includes a bound volume of all six installments of “Under the Moons of Mars,” a rare readable copy of this important first printing.

This paperback-bound volume contains all six installments of Burroughs’ ‘Under the Moons of Mars,’ which introduced the world to John Carter.
Burroughs took this fish-out-of-water formula and applied it to the popular jungle adventure stories of his time to create Tarzan, an English noble whose genealogy makes him inexplicably powerful in the jungle. It’s impossible to overstate how exciting Tarzan was in his day. Earlier issues of the same magazine have covers with quaint domestic scenes or contemplative adventurers, while Clinton Pettee’s classic cover for Tarzan’s first appearance shows him leaping headfirst into action, holding a knife to a lion’s throat. He was effectively the first modern action hero, and Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster used the same fish-out-of-water template a couple of decades later when they created Superman.
While the first appearance of a character or the first issue of a title is always notable and sought after, it’s the second appearance that proves that character’s success and decides whether they will live on and appear again. As such, “The Return of Tarzan” is an essential piece of pop culture history as well as something that has very, very few copies in existence today. This is a set you may never see again in one place; if that does somehow happen, I can’t imagine it being such an attractive and (mostly) unrestored group.


